The second episode of "Cost to Company", our brand new podcast on the biggest shifts in careers and workplaces is out. Listen now.
  • Stories
  • Visual Stories
  • Newsletters
  • Podcasts
Subscribe
India
Login
  • Login
  • Subscriptions
    • Individual Plans
    • Corporate Plans
    • Campus Plans
    • Gift a Subscription
  • Company
    • About Us
    • Team
    • Careers
    • Community
    • Blog
    • FAQ
  • Editorial
    • Narratives
    • All Stories
    • Newsletters
  • Contact Us
    • Write For Us
    • Queries
    • FAQ
  • Follow Us
    • Twitter
    • linkedIn
    • Instagram
India
  • Home
  • Search
  • Visual Stories
  • Newsletters
  • More
  • Subscriptions
    • Individual Plans
    • Corporate Plans
    • Campus Plans
    • Gift a Subscription
  • Company
    • About Us
    • Team
    • Careers
    • Culture
    • Community
    • Blog
    • FAQ
  • Editorial
    • Narratives
    • All Stories
    • Free Stories
    • Newsletters
  • Contact Us
    • Write for us
    • Queries
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • Facebook
  • Unlock more benefits of the The Ken Subscribe
  • Already Subscribed? Login

Sign Up

Login Login with google
OR

You’re signing up for an account which gives you access to a weekly free story and our archive of free stories. You will also receive a daily newsletter in your inbox. You can unsubscribe by clicking the link in the footer of all our emails.

Thanks! Logging you in

“Surprise is the greatest gift which life can grant us.”
– Boris Pasternak

Oops. An account with this email address already exists.
Have an account?
Login now

Sign Up

Login Login with google
OR
You seem to be already logged in from the following devices

We allow only two simultaneous login sessions per subscriber. If you continue, we will log you out from the above devices

Account successfully created

Almost Done!

Log in

Continue to your account at The Ken
Login Login with google
OR
Forgot Password?

Please add your name

Account details updated

Reset Password

Just enter your email address registered with
The Ken
Log in

Reset Password

Email Sent to:

Check your inbox for instructions to reset your password.

Sunny side up

The Nutgraf is a 10-min newsletter sent at 10 AM IST every Saturday. It connects the dots and synthesizes one big event in business, technology and finance that happened over the week in India. In a way you’ll never forget.

This is a paid newsletter that’s available exclusively to The Ken’s premium subscribers.

Just 10 mins long Synthesis not analysis Sometimes memes

Welcome back to The Nutgraf. 

The first week of 2020 is off to a great start. The Indian economy is at its worst in 42 years. The United States is trying to start another war in the Middle East, while their President is facing impeachment. Britain’s royal family is going through a Brexit of their own. And if WhatsApp forwards are to be believed, students at universities in India are responsible for all of this.

However, several other important things happened last week.

Let’s dive in. 


India’s solar ambitions soar…and stall

Two pieces of news broke last week. Both around solar energy in India. 

Both go back to something that was kicked off in 2015. 

First, Mint reported that several Southeast Asian countries were hesitant to join the International Solar Alliance (ISA). 

In case you don’t know, the ISA is an alliance of 121 countries that lie between the Tropic of Cancer and the Tropic of Capricorn – sunshine region of earth. It’s an alliance formed by India in 2015 with the aim of using solar energy to replace fossil fuels. Think of it as the new energy equivalent of Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC).  

Second, the Economic Times published a story that SoftBank was in talks to sell a majority stake in its Indian renewable energy company, SBG Cleantech. 

Set up in 2015 as a joint venture between SoftBank, Bharti Enterprises and Taiwan’s Foxconn Technology Group to build solar and wind parks, it was a key win for Prime Minister Narendra Modi and the Indian government’s push for clean energy. 

Look, I know what you are thinking. This looks like a familiar script. This is a story about the Indian government doing stupid things, and of SoftBank doing cartoon-villain evil things. 

Nope. That’s not this story.

Mostly because, and I can’t believe I am typing this out, solar energy was one of the very, very few things the Indian government got right. Not demonetisation. Not the Goods and Services Tax. Not the economy. Not tax structures. But solar energy policy. 

And not for a short period. But for nearly a decade. 

Then, suddenly, it noticed things were going well and said — hey wait a minute…

And proceeded to screw it up. 

Big Solar Audacious Goals are set…

Back in 2010, the Indian government launched an initiative called the National Solar Mission. The purpose of the mission was simple — establish India as a global leader in solar energy. 

At that time, India had an installed solar capacity of around 10 MW. To put this in perspective, the total installed capacity of all energy sources in India — coal, thermal, hydro, everything else was around 160 GW, of which just 10% was renewable energy. Solar energy stood at 0.006%. 

So the National Solar Mission said, okay, let’s set a big, audacious, goal. Let’s get solar to 20 GW by 2022. 

That’s a 2000X increase. In just 12 years. 

Look, if you know anything about India, you’ll know that goals like this are made all the time. Announcement is made. All the newspapers faithfully carry it in their pages. Speeches are made. Then everyone in government goes back to their day job of finding excuses to walk out of Parliament. 

This time though, something strange happened. 

India hit the 20 GW target in 2018. 

A full four years ahead of schedule. 

…and so the Indian government gets more ambitious

It’s worth asking, how did this happen? 

There are four things that are necessary to make solar energy work. 

  1. Cheap solar panels
  2. Cheap labour
  3. Cheap land
  4. Lots of sun

India had the last three. It was solar panels — the most important part that had to be fixed. And it got it thanks to a combination of smart policy, the right incentives and…China. 

The last bit is important. 

China was always interested in solar panels. It neatly fits with their traditional strengths. Manufacturing. Low technology. Global market. So, China really doubled down. Driven by subsidies, economies of scale, and capital, by 2012, China’s solar module manufacturers had the capacity to supply the entire world’s solar needs. 

As we wrote in a story last year, 

The resulting glut in the early 2010s led to the collapse of several Chinese—as well as American and European—manufacturers. Both the US and the European Union had slapped anti-dumping and anti-subsidy tariffs on Chinese solar cells and modules by the end of 2014. Undeterred, Chinese companies set their sights on a new, rapidly growing market—India.

So, in 2015, the Indian government got more ambitious. They raised the bar. Now the new target became 100 GW by 2022. 

Prices continued to fall. 

Much as in the US and Europe before, cheap Chinese equipment drove down costs for developers, giving India some of the lowest prices for solar-based electricity tariffs in the world. Tariffs fell to less than Rs 3 ($0.04) per kilowatt-hour as companies bid furiously for projects in 2016 and 2017, as imports accounted for about 90% of module sales.

India had arrived. In fact, in 2017-18, the Indian government added nearly 9 GW of solar energy — the highest ever. This is how it hit its 20 GW target early. 

Then something changed. 

In 2018, for the first time in five years, installations declined. 

The four horsemen arrive

Go back to that list of things that’s needed to make solar work. 

  1. Cheap solar panels
  2. Cheap labour
  3. Cheap land
  4. Lots of sun

The word cheap is there three times for a reason. It’s that important. Don’t forget, other forms of energy generation—like coal—have been around for over a century. Over this time, they have scaled globally, and that’s why they are nearly impossible to displace. The only way to do that is if solar energy can be produced more cheaply than any other form of energy. That’s why China’s role is so crucial. No other country could do what China did to drive down prices. Not now. Likely not ever. 

That’s the first thing you need to know. Pricing. The minute prices go up, solar energy goes away. Nobody cares about it anymore.

The second thing you need to do is who is responsible for power in India. In India, electricity is a state responsibility, not a central one. This means that the union government can set some policy, incentives, and nudge things along, but really, it’s up to individual states if they want to invest in electricity, and how to do it. 

One of the ways that the Indian government did this was to assure solar companies in India that state discoms (power companies) would purchase a certain part of their power requirement from them, even if it was more expensive. 

However, the states didn’t see it the same way. 

As Down to Earth reported, 

Another reason for the slump is governments’ insistence that plants sell power to discoms at unreasonably low tariffs. This trend began in 2017 after Rajasthan received a bid of Rs 2.44 per unit for the Bhadla Solar Park of Jodhpur.

That set the bar low and all states now expect extremely low tariffs, though operational costs there might be higher than they are at Bhadla. “Lower tariffs require a near perfect scenario where execution, collection and generation risks are minimal,” said Arul Shanmugasundram, chief executive of Mumbai-based Tata Power Solar.

Things were tight.

Then it got worse. 

Because in 2017, India launched the Goods and Services Tax. 

And it hit solar hard. 

Since many projects predated the tax, and the tariffs that project developers quoted while applying for the tenders were calculated without taking the tax into account, GST became an additional burden and turned the projects unviable.

The Centre asked the project developers to pay the tax and assured them reimbursement. This did not happen.

“Between 2017 and mid-2019, the industry paid Rs 8,000 crore in GST. But state governments refused to pay and instead approached the Appellate Tribunal For Electricity. We are now requesting the Centre for reimbursement,” said Manoj Upadhyay, founder and managing director, ACME Solar, a Gurugram-based firm.

Firms also said the government has framed the tax irrationally. “They tax solar projects assuming 30 percent of our cost is ‘services’ and 70 percent is ‘goods’. But ‘services’ are just 10 percent of what we do,” said Subrahmanyam Pulipaka, CEO, NSEFI. His argument could be driven by the higher tax the government levies on services (18 percent) than goods (5 percent). Still, GST has created complications.

Just as the sector was recovering from this double whammy, the Indian government hammered a third one home. 

It imposed a ‘safeguard duty’ of 25% on all solar modules imported from China. It did this to protect local manufacturers from Chinese imports, and to stimulate them. 

Nearly 90% of solar modules in India were imported from China. 

So did the duty help Indian manufacturers? 

Hell no.

As The Economic Times reported last year,

One year after India imposed an additional import duty on solar cells and modules to stimulate local production and reduce dependence on imports, no new domestic manufacturing unit has been set up, according to a renewable energy consultancy firm.

Before it was imposed, around 90% of solar panels and modules used in local solar projects were imported, mostly from China and Malaysia, as they were cheaper than locally manufactured ones.

The imposition of safeguard duty has not changed the situation.

Prices went up. In some cases, by as much as 20%. All of this led to solar companies producing lesser electricity. In September last year, the analyst firm Crisil put out a report titled ‘Return to Uncertainty’. The report noted that of the total 64 GW solar and wind capacity for which tenders were floated:

  • 31% was cancelled
  • 26% was undersubscribed
  • 10% was delayed 

Nobody wanted solar anymore. 

Then came the economic slowdown. 

Which led to states getting delayed payments from the central government. Which led to state discoms putting off payments to solar energy companies. Banks started to refuse to lend to solar companies. Slowly, solar power in India couldn’t find capital anymore. 

Also, some states started doing some strange things. In a damning story published by Mint a couple of months back titled ‘The setting sun on India’s solar dreams’, it noted

Policy changes have been sudden and unpredictable in other states as well. Taking a cue from Andhra Pradesh, Uttar Pradesh made an attempt to renegotiate old renewable energy tariffs. Gujarat decided last year that only projects which supply power to the state discom could use land within the state, flouting a central procurement agency’s rule for setting up projects under the interstate transmission system. Rajasthan, one of the most sought-after states for solar power plants, recently announced its decision to impose a charge of ₹2.5-5 lakh [$3,500 – $4500] per megawatt on all projects that sell power outside the state.

In 2020, the total installed capacity of solar energy in India stands at around 28 GW against its target of 100 GW by 2022. 

Last month, the Union Minister of Environment, Forest and Climate Change Prakash Javadekar claimed that India will add 67 GW in the next two years. 

At the United Nations Climate Action Summit last year, India’s Prime Minister, Narendra Modi increased India’s renewable energy target to 450 GW by 2030. 


The Competition Commission of India shows its cards

Last week, the Competition Commission of India (CCI), released a report titled ‘Market Study on E-commerce in India: Key Findings and Observations’. 

It’s just a market study, but it’s instructive in how the CCI, India’s antitrust regulator views the world of platforms and marketplaces. Most notably, the CCI focused on one key aspect which it believed leads to an imbalance in power between platforms and suppliers : information. 

To this end, the CCI suggested a range of measures to e-commerce companies to improve transparency. 

Some sounded quite reasonable

Bring out clear and transparent policies on discounts, including inter alia the basis of discount rates funded by platforms for different products/suppliers and the implications of participation/non-participation in discount schemes

Some sounded a bit…strange

Set out in the platforms’ terms and conditions a general description of the main search ranking parameters, drafted in plain and intelligible language and keep that description up to date.

Where the main parameters include the possibility to influence ranking against any direct or indirect remuneration paid by business users, set out a description of those possibilities and of the effects of such remuneration on ranking.

As I read it, the biggest takeaway is this: the CCI is going to take a dim view of platforms hiding or owning proprietary information from businesses who use the platform. This could be about its algorithms, or its policies, pricing or even user reviews. 

Of course, one could argue that the reason the distortion in the market exists against suppliers has less to do with information asymmetry and more to do with capital, technology and regulatory capture. 

But it’s a start.


What We Are…Reading

Bad Blood: Secrets and Lies in a Silicon Valley Startup by John Carreyrou

What is it about? 

Well, from Goodreads,

The full inside story of the breathtaking rise and shocking collapse of a multibillion-dollar startup, by the prize-winning journalist who first broke the story and pursued it to the end in the face of pressure and threats from the CEO and her lawyers.

I got to it a little late, thanks to a recommendation from Seema. For a change, I decided to listen to the audiobook instead this time. Narrated by Will Dameron, it’s a beautiful, brisk listen. 

And quite frankly, the story is insane. Really. It’s everything that investigative journalism should be, and rarely is. 


That’s about it from me this week. 

Subscribe to read this premium newsletter

Get this newsletter at Rs. 149/month Get The Stack at Rs. 199/month

13 Aug, 22

Disney+ Hotstar is not a streaming service

Praveen Krishnan

06 Aug, 22

Zepto is looking for a chair

Praveen Krishnan

30 Jul, 22No Signup Required

Why Cleartax isn’t free anymore

Praveen Krishnan

23 Jul, 22

Crypto is both dead and alive in India

Praveen Krishnan

16 Jul, 22Free

Why Unacademy is cutting free lunches for its employees

Praveen Krishnan

09 Jul, 22

How Flipkart crossed the secret e-commerce chasm

Praveen Krishnan

02 Jul, 22

Nobody wants to buy software in India

Praveen Krishnan

25 Jun, 22

The real reason why Uber and Ola drivers are cancelling your rides

Praveen Krishnan

18 Jun, 22Free

How Reliance made chaos into a ladder

Praveen Krishnan

11 Jun, 22

Two stories about UPI and Credit Cards

Praveen Krishnan

The Ken, on tap. Get the app

Download the Ken App and unlock the full potential of The Ken.

Subscriptions
  • Individual Plans
  • Corporate Plans
  • Campus Plans
  • Gift a Subscription
Company
  • About Us
  • Team
  • Careers
  • Culture
  • Community
  • Blog
CONTACT US
  • Write for us
  • Queries
  • FAQ
FOLLOW US
EDITORIAL
  • Narratives
  • All Stories
  • Free Stories
  • Newsletters
JOIN THE CONVERSATION

@NatesanSiv Been glued to The Ken for a while now. Gives you all you need to know in a non traditional language both concise and to the point. Well done @TheKenWeb

@Climateabhi @TheKenWeb gives personal touch to each and every mail subscriber newsletter, makes reading so engaging and connected! Platforms like The Ken are revolutionizing the way financial/business journalism is done in India.

Kenrise Media Private Limited, No.677, 1st Floor, Suite #643, 13th Cross, HSR Layout, Sector 1, Bangalore - 560102
  • 2021 The Ken
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy
Built at The Ken

Create Corporate Account

Success

Verification Code has been sent to your Email address

Update your email

Sorry, our free subscriptions require a real email id, because that's how we send you our daily stories. Please enter a valid email.

Account Detail Updated

Please Wait ...

Delete Account?

Are you sure you want to delete ()?

On deletion the user will become free starter

Cancel

Emails has been sent

Invite Sent!

We’ve sent your invite. Continue adding your teammates to your subscription here?

Add more members

Logout

Pending invitation

Join Team

Generate payment link

Enter the email address that you’d like us to send this payment link to. This could be your HR, finance representative, or anyone from your organization. A copy of this email will be sent to the team’s admin as well.

Email Sent Successfully

Corporate pricing applies to teams of 5 or more members only.

Thank you. We have received your request to post comments. You’ll hear from us soon.

Are you sure? Your subscription will expire at the end of your current subscription period.

Dismiss

Automatic payments successfully cancelled. You will not be charged again.

Your order invoice has been resent to your billing email. (You may have entered a different email than the one you’re logged in with)

Please upgrade to a paid account first

Are you sure? Canceling automatic payments can not be undone.

NO

You’ve got access!

Deepak Shahdadpuri has unlocked this article for you

Sponsor Details

Loading user data

Your email’s on its way!

We’ve emailed your gift link. Want us to send some more?

Yes, send more
T

The Ken has invited you to sign up for The Nutgraf by The Ken.

T

The Ken has invited you to sign up for The Nutgraf by The Ken.

Having your name allows us to address you personally in emails and on our website. That’s all, nothing else.

T

The Ken has invited you to sign up for The Nutgraf by The Ken.

Sign up for free by entering your primary email address. You can also login using your Google or Facebook account.

Login Login with google

Or

T

The Ken has invited you to sign up for The Nutgraf by The Ken.

Sign up for free by entering your primary email address. You can also login using your Google or Facebook account.

Login Login with google

Or

By registering, you will be signed-up for a free account with The Ken

Invite your friends and colleagues to read The Nutgraf.

Just copy and share your unique referral link to invite anyone to sign up for The Nutgraf.

COPY LINK

T

The Ken has added you as a partner. Read The Ken as a couple. Sign in to get started.

T

The Ken has added you as a partner. Read The Ken as a couple. Sign up to get started.

Having your name allows us to address you personally in emails and on our website. That’s all, nothing else.

T

The Ken has added you as a partner. Read The Ken as a couple.

The Ken’s stories are available only for paid subscribers. As a partner, you can now access The Ken subscription. For free. Just activate your account to get started.

T

The Ken has added you as a partner. Read The Ken as a couple.

The Ken’s stories are available only for paid subscribers. As a partner, you can now access The Ken subscription. For free. Just activate your account to get started.

By registering, you will be signed-up for a free account with The Ken

Sharp, original,
insightful, analytical

Alert

Our anti-piracy system has flagged your account for suspicious activity and has temporarily paused your account. This may happen due to a number of reasons.

If you think that this was done in error, please get in touch with us at [email protected].

Are you sure?

You will be changing your registered email address to access your account. All email newsletters will be delivered to the new email ID.

Dismiss

Searching...

No results found for .

Top Searches

20 Feb, 20

OYO's Battle of the Bulge

Sumanth Raghavendra

03 Jan, 20

Bajaj, Razorpay, Zerodha carry the Indian fintech torch

Arundhati Ramanathan

04 Dec, 19

Selling to those who can't pay: human cost of modern banking

Arundhati Ramanathan, Shreedhar Manek

20 Jan, 20

OYO's long march—retreat of the red army

Abinaya Vijayaraghavan, Savio D'Souza

03 Dec, 19

Reliance Jio travels first-class on the tariff hike gravy train

Pratap Vikram Singh

22 Jan, 20

Zomato swallows Uber Eats India — just desserts or a bitter pill?

Sumanth Raghavendra

12 Dec, 19

Ajit Mohan to Sanjay Gupta: Facebook, Google hot on Hotstar's big stars

Jon Russell, Pranav Shankar

27 Dec, 19

Flipkart, Amazon, Snapdeal: 10 years, 3 players, 1 e-commerce story

Durga M Sengupta

16 Jan, 20

Project Manager is dead. Long live the Product Manager

Olina Banerji, Shreedhar Manek

See all results for .

Welcome to The Ken

As a part of the Learning and Development program at Myntra-Jabong, you have complete access to 300+ original daily stories over the next year, 500+ previously published stories and our comment sections. Also, do keep an eye out for our exclusive subscriber-only iOS and Android apps which will be rolled out for you shortly.

Happy Reading!

By continuing to browse our site you agree to our use of cookies to improve our performance and enhance your user experience.
Accept

Contact Us

  • For Queries
    [email protected]
  • For Feedback
    Write to us here

We’ll get back to you within 2-7 working days .

Have a great story idea for The Ken?

We welcome contributors from journalists, subject matter experts, and anyone who has a good story to tell.

Learn More
Follow us to stay updated

Twitter

Facebook

LinkedIn

Activating your subscription